Monday, August 20, 2007

Week 6- Chapter 6 Discussion Questions

1. Would you include balancing comment (in the form of a source's statement) in a story if you knew that the statement was untrue but could not say so or prove that it was untrue, and the source insisted that the comment be included?
If the source insisted that the comment was true and it was going to balance the issue, contributing to a fair story than I would have to use the comment. If the statement could not be proved untrue than there is no way a reporter can simply ignore the source based on their own judgement alone. It would be especially important to use the quote if it rendered otherwise present bias in the article.

2. Because you could not locate a source for balancing comment, would you withold a story on which you have worked hard? Would your decision change if you knew that an opposing newspaper was planning to run a similar story, reducing the value of your effort?
No, I would still use the story without the balancing comment, but I would then work very hard over the next day in order to source a balancing comment, so if necessary I could present an answering article on the following day. The second half of the question is part of the reason why I would run with the story, in the news environment of today a reporter needs to stay competitive otherwise they will be rapidly overtaken by the other newspapers.

3. You are sent to report from the scene of a major uncontrolled fire in a high-rise building. People are trapped inside. What dangers would you look out for? Who would you interview? When would you start writing your story?
On arriving at the scene there would be a number of dangers that I would look out for. Obviously, danger to oneself would be the key priority, as there is no point getting too close to the scene and putting myself and others in danger. There are people already trapped inside who need emergency attention so I would not place myself in a dangeous distance to the scene. I would keep my distance from the fire until it was controlled and all the trapped people were removed from the building.
I would seek to interview any witnesses that were willing to comment. After the rescue was under control I would then interview the authorities such as the fire fighters, police and ambulance officers. If the victims of the fire were not too traumatised and physically injured I would try to interview them as well.
I would start to write the story as soon as I had the information from the scene and had interviewed at least two of the parties mentioned above. If I wasn't completely satisfied with the facts and information that I obtained I would write a story and then seek further interviews, filing a second story on the following day.

4. From your reading of news stories, do you think the inverted pyramid remains the most effective method of structuring material?
Yes, I still hold the opinion that the inverted pyramid is the best way to structure a news story. I do agree that in some cases a different structure may be more suited, such as the narrative structure, however in most news story cases the inverted pyramid provides the best outline. It allows the most important information to be readily accessible to the reader, which supports the way of life most people now adopt. Reading on the run has increasingly become the trend, as people simply do not have enough time to sit down and read the newspaper from front to back. The inverted pyramid structure allows these people to obtain the most relevant facts quickly before they get bored or run out of time. This structure is definitely the master of structures, in that a journalist should ensure they can write effectively with this structure before experimenting with the others.

No comments: