Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Week 14- Blog Issue

As this is my last blog entry for this course, I would like to take this opportunity to comment on my experiences of the course throughout the semester. I think it has been quite beneficial to me as a striving journalism student. It has taught me many of the practical facts of journalism and the skills that I will be required to have when I begin my career. I strongly believe that having a degree is very beneficial for an applicant for a journalistic position. I also realise the value of work experience throughout one’s degree and most importantly prior to searching for a job. I have made the decision that I need to undertake some short hand and touch typing classes as these are skills that are frequently required, yet not taught at university.

I feel that this course follows on well from the Introduction to Professional Writing course in semester one. I have learnt to further refine my writing skills in different forms of journalistic writing. I think the blog component of the assessment criteria has been beneficial in not only understanding the readings, but also in challenging one to consider how they would deal with the many varied situations that may arise in the life of a journalist.

I am really enjoying my degree so far and can only hope that next year is just as fulfilling.

Week 14- Discussion Questions

1. You are a reporter and an important source invites you to a dinner. The source says it is the only way you will get the information you need and insists on paying. Based on past practice, your newspaper will refuse to reimburse your costs. What do you do?
I would still pay for the cost myself. Even though this may be seen as a minor case of chequebook journalism, if the story was huge than it would be worth my personal funds in the long run. This may seem unethical to some, but the benefits from printing a fabulous story which came from the dinner would far outweigh the monetary cost of the dinner. I would not let the source pay because they would then have ammunition against me as well as the news organisation.

2. While the travel editor was on sick leave, you took a two-week trip to Spain, courtesy of a major airline. During the trip, the airline insisted that the resulting story be positive, and demanded the right to vet and change your copy, saying an advertising contract depended upon it. It was the worst trip of your life. What do you do?
This is a tough situation, because I would want to keep the airline happy to ensure the contract remained however as a journalist it is my responsibility to provide honest information to the public. If I were to promote the airline as wonderful, I would not be being honest. No matter what, no outside person should be able to change a journalist’s copy, only those within the media organisation have that right. After much consideration I would portray the airline as they advertise it and ensure the story is objective. I would avoid adding my opinion, just the opinion of others. I need to be fair to the airline, but honest and ethical to the public as well.

3. A reliable source tells you of an error in your story, which has been published in this morning’s paper. This means that you must notify the editor and compose a correction for publication. But the source is not concerned about the error and insists that this not be done. Instead they want you to write another small story, based on a new angle. You admission error will cost you a pay rise. What do you do?
I would compose the correction for publication regardless, not because of the pay rise issue but because any mistake in an ethical organisation should be corrected. Errors negatively affect the reputation of the media organisation and although this particular source may not mind, other potential sources may see it as unethical and disreputable. I would also agree to write the new small story for the source as a personal display of apology to them for the mistake. Hopefully, this strategy would keep all parties happy.

4. You are the court reporter on a major regional newspaper. A teenager convicted of a prostitution offence approaches you. She is beside herself with emotion and says that if you write the story her parents will disown her, her friends will shun her, and worst of all, her partner-who is terminally ill, who she is supporting financially and emotionally in the last days of his life, and who thinks she works in a bank-will not be able to handle finding out how she really earns her money. Your newspaper normally always reports such cases. What will you do? Why?
This is a very newsworthy topic, however I would not write the story at the present time. Firstly, it is against the law to report particular details about something that is occurring in the children’s court. Secondly, it is a major regional newspaper; therefore it is highly unlikely that another news organisation is going to beat me to the story. It would be in the best interest of all parties involved if I held off the story until the situation progressed. I realise journalists need to be hard-nosed, however in some situations ethics and morals do influence the choice of the journalist as to whether they print a story.

Week 13- Blog Issue

This week I would like to talk about the guest speakers who presented at the lecture. One was a radio journalist and the other a television journalist. Both women completed their studies at the University of Newcastle. Both of the journalists explained what their jobs entailed, how they got to where they are, what they think about their jobs, and advice for journalism students and where they are headed in the future.

I was particularly interested in the second speaker, Jane Goldsmith, who is a television journalist at NBN. Although I have a strong interest in newspaper and magazine journalism, television journalism is another area that I am considering. A very important point that I took home from the presentation was to complete as much work experience as possible. To date I have completed work experience at ‘The Northern Daily Leader’ in Tamworth and have organised to go to ‘TV Week’ in Sydney in January for some more experience. I agree with Jane that it is beneficial to undertake work experience in the different media platforms in order to understand how each form works together and complements each other in the media environment. The presentations prompted me to strive to get an on-going work experience position throughout my next years of study to build more contact base and further enhance my career in the long term.

Week 13- Chpt 17- Discussion Questions

1. You are a newspaper editor. One of your reporters has made an honest mistake that defamed someone. You publish an apology. The person defamed is not satisfied and wants you to print a full-page feature story promoting her business or she will sue. What will you do?
I would print the feature story but only on her business. I would give no more attention to the act of defamation as I have already published a formal apology. For the sake of one day’s space in the paper, I would simply publish the feature story.

2. Would you support a ‘public figure’ defence for the media that would sharply limit the rights of public figures, ranging from premiers to cricketers and rock stars, to take out defamation suits against the media? Why?
Yes, I would support it because these people strive to get in the media all the time. They basically rely on the media as part of their promotional campaigns, yet when something is printed about them that they do not favour however little it may be, they make a defamation claim. If they want to be covered a lot in the media than they need to create a positive relationship with the media, one that can be relied upon not to turn on them at any opportunity.

3. You have promised a confidential source that you will not identify her. However, you discover that what she told you is untrue. Your newspaper is sued for defamation. You try to contact the person but she has vanished. Do you reveal her identity in court? Why?
Yes, the company would reveal her identity, as she is not only someone who has committed a crime concerning the media organisation but is now also a missing person and could be in danger. If I was to keep quiet about her, it would only worsen the already quickly deepening problem.

Week 13- Chpt 13- Discussion Questions

1. What do media companies need to do in relation to convergence before they can expect their journalists to work in converged news rooms?
Once a media company decides it is going to converge it needs to ensure adequate training opportunities are offered to each journalist. All journalists need to be kept informed and taught how to create the new type of media in order for them to accept the company changes. It is quite simple, if the convergence is forced upon the journalists they are not going to cooperate, whereas if they are kept informed and educated they are much more likely to accept and embrace the changes.

2. What would be the likely outcome if someone who just wanted to work as a print journalist, because they would be nervous on television, was told by the company they worked for that they must report for television as well as print?
The most likely outcome would be that the journalist would not agree with the position. In some cases, the journalist would probably leave the company and seek a position elsewhere that suited their likes and had a position solely as a print journalist. Some journalists however, might embrace the situation and begin to learn skills of television reporting in order to fulfill their job requirements.

3. Is journalistic convergence just a trendy fad that will run its course then be forgotten about?
Definitely not, journalistic convergence is something that is definitely here to stay. In the future the trend is only going to intensify in the world. As time progresses and technology advances more and more print and television journalism will appear on the Internet. Some people even suspect that the other more traditional media forms may eventually be faded out, with people relying mostly on the Internet to gain their news.

4. What will be the long-term outcome in Australia of relaxed cross-media ownership laws?
The long-term outcome will be that news organisations will continue to need to work through online materials to remove stories that may contain details or events that have become sub-judice when a court case begins. If the laws are relaxed than the companies will continue to print the same information online as in newspapers, however the information published on the Internet then becomes an archive available more or less permanently and needs to be removed when defamation arises.

5. If you had a crystal ball, what would you tell about the future of radio, television, and the web?
I believe that in the future the same information that is reported on the radio and television will be transformed into web sites for each station and program. The information will be converged to be made available as web text on the online web sites. I also believe that radio and television reporting will be replayed on the Internet, therefore making the listening of the radio and watching the television unnecessary. I do not believe that the web will totally take over the other more traditional forms, but it will gain even more popularity than it already has.

6. Should the idea of multi-skilling be integrated into every course in university journalism studies? Why?
Yes, it is important in this day and age that every journalism student learns not only how to multi-skill but also the importance of multi-skilling. In most cases, a journalism position will only require the journalist to be able to perform their main function, such as print reporting as well as the online component, or television reporting and the online component. In some smaller organisations however, the journalist may be required to take on many of the roles in the newsroom. Multiple skills and education will be needed to fulfill this requirement. Multi-skilling is definitely a component that is a huge advantage to a beginning journalist.

7. Is society getting to a point where life as we know it could not survive without the Internet and web?
For many people this is the case. Some people still do not have the Internet and live their lives just as they always have; however for others they would not be able to perform their daily occupations or duties without the Internet. Much communication is performed through the use of the Internet. In terms of communicating news, we could easily survive without the Internet, but many companies would not be able to survive and therefore many jobs would be lost if they did not have the Internet and the web.

Week 12- Blog Issue

This week I would like to focus on the qualities of both a radio journalist and a television journalist. A radio journalist must have many journalistic skills, such as honesty, accuracy, reliability, and the ability to meet deadlines, but they also need to focus strongly on their voice and speaking skills. It is important for a radio journalist to consider the speed, accuracy and brevity of their voice. These are key qualities that must be learnt and refined to a high standard. However, a radio journalist can have all the above skills but they still will not be the best reporter if they do not have a voice for radio. Just like a news reporter needs to have the ‘glam’ factor, a radio reporter needs to have a good voice. Journalists often undertake education and voice schools to enhance their public and broadcast voice.

Like radio journalists, television journalists need to acquire all the skills of a journalist. However, they must also present themselves in an appropriate manner. As television portrays a visual image to the responder, the reporter must have good posture, excellent diction, as well as feel comfortable in front of the camera. Often a person will either feel comfortable or not, if not than they have to get used to it quickly if they want to be on television. Although a television reporter needs to be ‘glamorous’, the chapter highlighted an important point: that a semi-competent but excellent looking presenter may not always be viewed favourably over an intelligent, competent reporter with an ‘average’ but well groomed appearance. These factors need to be carefully considered when selecting beginning journalists.

Week 12- Discussion Questions

1. Do you think the ABC should be privatised? What impact might this have on broadcast journalism? If you disagree, could the government funding process be made less ‘political’?
I think that it should be privatised, as this may decrease the bias in broadcast journalism. As the government is currently controlling the ABC the journalists tend to report on issues demanded by the government or that are based on their opinion due to government influence. If it was privatised, broadcast journalists would have greater opportunity to report more accurate facts and the area of broadcast journalism would grow even more.

2. You are a television news director with two strong job applications. One is from a ‘telegenic’ male, 28, with reasonable skill and experience. The other is from a female, 38. She is of ‘average’ appearance but has considerable skill and experience. Your presenter reporting staff consists of four females and one male, none older than 32. Who do you hire, and why?
I would hire the woman. Although a ‘glamour’ image is required for a television reporter other important attributes are very important. I would prefer to hire a journalist that is competent in their preparation and reporting, with a well groomed appearance, good posture and clear diction than someone who is glamorous but semi-competent. Also the ability to feel at ease in front of the camera is a major criterion for the interviewees to meet.

3. Given the strengths and weaknesses of each medium, which do you think is the ‘best communicator’ on any given story: radio, television, the web, or newspapers?
I believe that television is the best communicator. Although it cannot give as much detailed information as the web or newspapers, it can provide enough information in its limited time to present the public with the news, including all the necessary facts. Due to the lack of reporting time, the television journalist is very skilled in ensuring that the most important facts are displayed. The television also has the advantage of being able to show pictures of the news, which often are more powerful than actual words. Also, in interviews the expressions and emotions of the subject are viewed by the responder, as they see as well as here the news story which allows for a more detailed interpretation of the event.

4. During the last federal election campaign do you think the broadcast media focused more on issues or personalities? What could have been done better?
For this question I will discuss the current federal election campaign, as there is one in action at present due to the election on the 24th November, 2007. At present, the media are focusing more on the personalities of Kevin Rudd and John Howard. To be honest, the media are getting quite personal with their stories. I feel it would be better covered if the media focused more on the political issues and what each party are going to provide that will benefit Australia. This is what the majority of the public would rather be hearing. The personal aspects of either party are not the issue at hand and therefore should not be given so much attention from the media.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Week 11- Chapter 11 Blog Issue

As a journalism student I find it important to understand the different rounds that a journalist might take. The main rounds of local government, police, court and parliamentary reporting are all considerations for a journalist. Personally, I am particularly interested in the police and court reporting rounds. I understand that there are many laws and regulations to follow in order to effectively report in both of these positions. While it is important to remember that the main duty of a journalist is to report to the public the information that they are entitled to, one must also consider the laws to be followed and obligations they owe to the person in question. Mistakes in this area not only cost a journalist their job, but can also land them in jail.

This week I also wish to comment on an issue that is in the news at the present. Yesterday, Monday 15th October, 2007, three year five students were reported to have taken ecstasy tablets in the belief that they were candy. There are many issues surrounding this claim. Firstly, what was the child’s brother doing with ecstasy in the first place, and secondly did the children not have suspicions about the presentation of the so-called “candy”. These are just two of my queries. I feel that there are a lot blank spots in the case, however with what I have just learnt from the chapter I understand that the journalist would be quite restricted as to what exactly they can publish. This type of case is a prime example of a situation that will warrant follow-up stories.

Week 11- Chapter 11 Discussion Questions

1. You are a police reporter for a major city newspaper. A young man who seems credible tells you that he has been bashed by an off-duty police officer. He has witnesses and a medical report. A police officer tells you that no one will speak to you again if the newspaper runs anything, regardless of who writes it. The chief-of-staff says that if you do not write the story you will be removed from the round. What do you do?
Firstly, I would try to negotiate with the chief-of-staff and the police officer to see if either the police officer will cooperate or the chief-of-staff has an alternative angle to take on the story. Otherwise, I would write the story and submit it for publication. Although the police officer has made this threat, he may not be in the authoritative position to make such a comment and it may not be a legitimate claim. The police officer may simply be trying to cover the reputation of the other accused policeman. Also, there are other sources that the journalist will be able to gain information from. I would have to be careful in reporting only the basic facts to avoid contempt of court and misleading information on someone not yet found innocent or guilty. At the end of the day, the chief-of-staff is your boss.

2. A distraught woman convicted of stealing a pair of stockings from a store approaches you after her court case and says that she will commit suicide if you publish anything. Your newspaper has a policy of publishing all such cases, but it will never know about this one unless you reveal it. You really believe the woman might be suicidal. What do you do? Why?
I realise that journalists need to be thick-skinned and hard-nosed, however in this situation I would let the story go. Considering the lady’s claims to committing suicide I do not think that the story is that interesting and would be found enormously ground breaking and interesting to the public. The conviction is only minor and the woman obviously needs psychological help, not further humiliation in the media.

3. A very famous and very attractive personality gets hopelessly drunk at a party, causes chaos, and on the way home is picked up for drink-driving. You get a tip from a police contact and attend court where the personality is convicted of being three times over the limit, fined, and disqualified from driving. You are the only journalist in court. The personality later phones you and begs you not to write the story because it will ruin their career. They are so desperate they offer everything from sex to money and a free holiday if you do not report on the case. What will you do? Why?
I would report the case. It is my duty to serve the public and provide them with the public information they are entitled to. Regardless as to whether the person being reported on is an everyday person or a high profile person, the standard is still the same. I would therefore maintain the fairness in my reporting. It is similar to the 2004 case of Jeff Shaw’s criminal actions that regardless of his position within society were still published. This situation is no different and under no circumstances would I accept bribes in any form.

4. Although it is against the law, a juror in a high-profile murder trial approaches you and says there will be a hung jury in the case because two jury members have accepted bribes of $100 000 each from two corrupt high-ranking police officers who have paid the money on condition that the jurors do not return a guilty verdict. What will you do? Why?
I would stay quiet about the claim as it is against the law for a journalist to communicate with a juror prior to such a court case. I would attend the court case and then build my article on what happens in the court. If I was to take this information and publish it, I would not only be committing a crime myself but I would also be continuing a chain of corruption.

Tuesday, October 9, 2007

Week 10- Chapter 10 Blog Issue

There are many different roles within the newsroom. These include from the top of the hierarchy down, the managing editor or editor-in-chief à the editor à the deputy editor or associate editor à the news editor à the chief-of-staff, chief sub-editor, chief photographer/photo editor à the journalists, sub-editors, photographers/artists. Although the sub-editors and journalists appear to be on the same level within the newsroom, this is not the case. Journalists are at the bottom of the hierarchy. The sub-editor is usually older, more experienced and paid better than a general reporter. This is based on the fact that a sub-editor is a journalist, they need to have been reporting for a considerable time and learnt many skills before they are equipped to become a sub-editor.

Personally, I was particularly interested in the relationship between the journalist and the sub-editor. Often each blames the other for mistakes that tend to be exposed in the final copy, but I think it is important in any organisation to work as a team. If each journalist supported each sub-editor and vice-versa then fewer mistakes would be evident.

I found this chapter very interesting and helpful for someone who is planning on entering the journalistic field. It is fundamental to understand the different roles within the newsroom and what each role expects of the personnel involved. It gives one an idea of the growth that is available in a reporter’s career.

Week 10- Chapter 10 Discussion Questions

1. A confidential source has tipped you off about what could be the story of the year, but they would prefer you to wait a day to write it. The source admits that another media outlet might have it too. You feel you need at least two days on it to do a good job. But it’s been a slow news day, and if you tell the chief-of-staff, you will be expected to write it to the best of your ability today. What do you do?
If it is a slow news day then I would grab it this opportunity immediately. This could be an excellent story as mentioned by the source and there is no way I would risk another newspaper distributing the lead story. I would speak to the chief-of-staff and use my day to produce the story to the best of my ability. Although the source has said that they would prefer if I waited, they have obviously tipped another outlet off as well who are more than likely going to try to print their own version of the story. I would go ahead and take advantage of the potential of the situation.

2. After a tip from an inside source you work on an article about filth in the kitchen of a major resort which has allegedly resulted in several guests and staff becoming ill. In the final stages of preparing your article you seek comment from the resort’s manager, who is hostile and refuses to comment. A short time later you receive a phone call from a leading public relations practitioner who tells you that the resort has been losing money and any bad publicity would force it to close with the loss of 120 jobs. Your source is one of the people who could be out of work. What will you do? Why?
Obviously I would consult with my chief-of-staff for advice, but my general opinion would be that the main function of journalism is to provide the public with the information that they are entitled to. If I was to withhold this information I would not be fulfilling my role as a journalist. For this reason I would go ahead and write the story. The fact that the problem is affecting the health of the general public as well as the refusal of the manager to comment both highlight a major problem that needs to be recognised not only by the public, but also by the relevant officials. In the short term jobs may be lost, however the long term benefits for both the employees and the public will be much better if the story is printed.

3. You are the late sub-editor for a daily newspaper. It is nearly 10pm. A man who identifies himself as a solicitor rings and says that a judge issued an order, after the journalist departed, prohibiting publication of a defendant’s name. He sounds drunk. The story, with the defendant’s name, is on the front page, which is about to be sent to the press. There is no time to call anyone without delaying the production process. What do you do?
After consideration, I would go ahead with the story. I realise there are huge defamation issues that would arise if the caller was legitimate, but too many factors challenge his story. Firstly, any journalist working in a professional organisation waits to the end of a court hearing before leaving and would therefore hear a vital point such as prohibited publication of the defendant’s name. Secondly, the caller has had all afternoon to contact the organisation, but has waited until 10pm at night. Lastly, the caller sounds drunk, which completely destroys his credibility as a solicitor or any other person with legitimate information on the matter. All these factors lead one to the conclusion that the phone call is most probably a hoax.

4. You are a junior journalist and you find yourself caught in the middle of an argument between the editor, who wants you to take one angle on a crime story, and the police rounds reporter who says the editor does not understand the full implications of the story and you should take a totally different angle. What will you do? Why?
I would listen to the editor as they are at much higher position than me and most probably have control over my position within the organisation. Although the police rounds reporter might have more knowledgeable on this particular issue, but the editor most probably would have more experience with the paper and in journalism itself.

Monday, October 1, 2007

Week 9- Chapter 15 Additional Blog

This chapter on computer assisted reporting (CAR) is very interesting and relevant considering the communication age that we are currently operating in. As I am completing my degree now, it is a strong belief that the need to be educated in the area of CAR is only going to increase by the time I have completed my degree and am entering into the professional field of journalism.

It is important to be aware of the different ways in which people can present unauthorised and incorrect information. The chapter points out the various methods of checking the authenticity and accuracy of sites. I found the section on the different URL extensions very interesting. The extension on a URL is so easily ignored when performing a search; this has reminded me to check it, as normally I would not always remember.

It is amazing to consider the fact that a form of technology that is so beneficial to society can also have so many negative impacts. These disadvantages must be first hand knowledge to all journalists in order to take the correct measures to avoid negative impacts growing into bigger problems. As mentioned, the technological world is only going to further develop as time evolves; therefore CAR is something that all journalists should embrace.

Week 9- Chapter 15 Discussion Questions

1. You are about to graduate with a degree in journalism. You have taken web writing, digital photojournalism, and CAR courses as well as completing a newspaper internship. There are two job offers. One is from a small but financially stable weekly newspaper several hours from your capital city. The other is from a new online publication based in your capital city. It offers almost twice the pay but will not give you more than a six-month contract. Which job will you choose, and why?
Although I would be tempted to take the latter position as I have studied courses that would be advantageous in this job, I would take the weekly newspaper position. Just graduating from university I believe that experience in journalistic writing is more important than the dollar value one is receiving. The experience and knowledge gained from a news organisation like the first one is invaluable in establishing one’s journalism career. My reasoning also comes from the fact that personally I am more interested in newspaper writing in its traditional form, and although some sacrifices would have to be made such as moving, I believe that the experience, knowledge and stability gained would be great for a beginning journalist.

2. Your newspaper does not have a policy on using quotations or paraphrasing from email interviews. A local politician tells you she will not consent to an interview with you on a crucial issue unless it is via email. You need both comments and factual information from her but suspect you won’t get the spontaneous, reactive comment and detail you need by deadline with an email interview. What do you do?
I would continue to email the interview to her and get what information I could from it. I would also complete background information, get quotes and information from other related sources and use archived information to build a basic background. I would continue to request a personal interview with the source, but if time ran out and I couldn’t get this then I would simply have to use the information already obtained as well as the email interview. I would use quotations out of the email, just as though they were normal quotes.

3. While conducting a CAR search on the web you come across some information which clearly indicates that a story ‘written’ by a colleague was plagiarized from a website. What will you do?
I would go straight to the colleague and present my findings. If he/she was not willing to correct the problem I would then consider contacting my editor-in-chief about the matter. I realise that my colleague would not be happy with this decision, however if the plagiarism was picked up by another organisation or a copyright organisation not only that particular journalist’s career would be affected but also the entire news organisation. One’s own reputation could be damaged in this process; therefore it is important to be proactive.

4. A person you know nothing about has sent you an email from a Hotmail address saying they have information which will bring the government down. The writer says they are on the run from the police, will only meet you at 2am on the bank of a river in an unpopulated area, and you must be alone. You reply to the email seeking more information and a telephone number. There is no reply. What will you do? Why?
I would ignore the email until further information is given. Clearly it is a hoax as it has been sent from a hotmail account, they are on the run from the police and won’t give out any authoritarian information. It would take something pretty major to bring the government down and no single journalist is going to run a story on a hoax email that cannot even be supported in a correct manner.

5. When searching the web for a particular quotation attributed to Daniel Defoe and his book Robinson Crusoe you find six instances of the quote. Three of them say exactly the same thing, and the other three say exactly the same thing as each other but they are different from the first three. How will you decide which quotation, if either, is correct?
I would look at the source of the information. Firstly, I would consider the URL and its extension. If one of the sites had a well known and attributable extension than I would use its quote. I would then consider who created the website and therefore wrote the quote. If this person is also authoritative and known to have the knowledge of the book and its quotes than I would choose it’s quote to use.