Sunday, September 9, 2007

Week 9 Discussion Questions

1. Which would you choose: a direct quotation that is accurate but unclear and embarrassing to the speaker, or one that is clear but is inexact and makes the speaker appear more eloquent than he or she really is?
If the fact that the speaker appeared more eloquent did not affect the meaning that the reader took from the story and the inexactness was only small than I would use the clear and inexact quote. However, if the quote had been changed a lot and it changed the meaning of the story than I would have to use the first accurate quote.

2. Is it ever justified for a journalist to intimidate a source with a threat of ‘public exposure’ to get important public information?
No, this should never be performed by an ethical journalist. The journalist can only construct a story on what the interviewee will tell them and the other background research they have performed. If the interviewee will not expose certain facts than the journalist will have to look elsewhere to different sources in an attempt to obtain the public information.

3. Is it a reasonable strategy for a journalist-male or female- to use ‘personal chemistry’ to get information from sources when there is public interest at stake?
No, it is not reasonable or ethical. However, it is amazing what a journalist will do these days to get a story. It would be very unethical to do this and therefore not a good strategy, but a closer relationship between the interviewee and the journalist would assist the journalist in obtaining better facts and opinions.

4. What potential dangers could come back to haunt a journalist who gets too close to a source?
The journalist could be charged for defamation if something that they print is not quite true and defames the subject. The journalist may be led to believe something and because of the close relationship believe the source, but in the long term be proven untrue which could defame another party. Another example would be if the relationship turns negative, the subject may change their mind and accuse the journalist of printing untrue facts.

5. Who is the most inarticulate, word-mangling public figure regularly in the news at present? Should you feel sorry for them and clean up their direct quotes or let them stew in their own frying pan?
Due to the APEC Summit in Sydney currently I would probably have to say George W. Bush. It is a little bit hard to clean up his direct quotes because he is doing a lot of radio broadcasts where his speeches are recorded and therefore cannot be edited. It all depends on whether changing their quotes will affect the story as to whether written quotes are changed.

No comments: