Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Week 14- Discussion Questions

1. You are a reporter and an important source invites you to a dinner. The source says it is the only way you will get the information you need and insists on paying. Based on past practice, your newspaper will refuse to reimburse your costs. What do you do?
I would still pay for the cost myself. Even though this may be seen as a minor case of chequebook journalism, if the story was huge than it would be worth my personal funds in the long run. This may seem unethical to some, but the benefits from printing a fabulous story which came from the dinner would far outweigh the monetary cost of the dinner. I would not let the source pay because they would then have ammunition against me as well as the news organisation.

2. While the travel editor was on sick leave, you took a two-week trip to Spain, courtesy of a major airline. During the trip, the airline insisted that the resulting story be positive, and demanded the right to vet and change your copy, saying an advertising contract depended upon it. It was the worst trip of your life. What do you do?
This is a tough situation, because I would want to keep the airline happy to ensure the contract remained however as a journalist it is my responsibility to provide honest information to the public. If I were to promote the airline as wonderful, I would not be being honest. No matter what, no outside person should be able to change a journalist’s copy, only those within the media organisation have that right. After much consideration I would portray the airline as they advertise it and ensure the story is objective. I would avoid adding my opinion, just the opinion of others. I need to be fair to the airline, but honest and ethical to the public as well.

3. A reliable source tells you of an error in your story, which has been published in this morning’s paper. This means that you must notify the editor and compose a correction for publication. But the source is not concerned about the error and insists that this not be done. Instead they want you to write another small story, based on a new angle. You admission error will cost you a pay rise. What do you do?
I would compose the correction for publication regardless, not because of the pay rise issue but because any mistake in an ethical organisation should be corrected. Errors negatively affect the reputation of the media organisation and although this particular source may not mind, other potential sources may see it as unethical and disreputable. I would also agree to write the new small story for the source as a personal display of apology to them for the mistake. Hopefully, this strategy would keep all parties happy.

4. You are the court reporter on a major regional newspaper. A teenager convicted of a prostitution offence approaches you. She is beside herself with emotion and says that if you write the story her parents will disown her, her friends will shun her, and worst of all, her partner-who is terminally ill, who she is supporting financially and emotionally in the last days of his life, and who thinks she works in a bank-will not be able to handle finding out how she really earns her money. Your newspaper normally always reports such cases. What will you do? Why?
This is a very newsworthy topic, however I would not write the story at the present time. Firstly, it is against the law to report particular details about something that is occurring in the children’s court. Secondly, it is a major regional newspaper; therefore it is highly unlikely that another news organisation is going to beat me to the story. It would be in the best interest of all parties involved if I held off the story until the situation progressed. I realise journalists need to be hard-nosed, however in some situations ethics and morals do influence the choice of the journalist as to whether they print a story.

No comments: