Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Week 12- Discussion Questions

1. Do you think the ABC should be privatised? What impact might this have on broadcast journalism? If you disagree, could the government funding process be made less ‘political’?
I think that it should be privatised, as this may decrease the bias in broadcast journalism. As the government is currently controlling the ABC the journalists tend to report on issues demanded by the government or that are based on their opinion due to government influence. If it was privatised, broadcast journalists would have greater opportunity to report more accurate facts and the area of broadcast journalism would grow even more.

2. You are a television news director with two strong job applications. One is from a ‘telegenic’ male, 28, with reasonable skill and experience. The other is from a female, 38. She is of ‘average’ appearance but has considerable skill and experience. Your presenter reporting staff consists of four females and one male, none older than 32. Who do you hire, and why?
I would hire the woman. Although a ‘glamour’ image is required for a television reporter other important attributes are very important. I would prefer to hire a journalist that is competent in their preparation and reporting, with a well groomed appearance, good posture and clear diction than someone who is glamorous but semi-competent. Also the ability to feel at ease in front of the camera is a major criterion for the interviewees to meet.

3. Given the strengths and weaknesses of each medium, which do you think is the ‘best communicator’ on any given story: radio, television, the web, or newspapers?
I believe that television is the best communicator. Although it cannot give as much detailed information as the web or newspapers, it can provide enough information in its limited time to present the public with the news, including all the necessary facts. Due to the lack of reporting time, the television journalist is very skilled in ensuring that the most important facts are displayed. The television also has the advantage of being able to show pictures of the news, which often are more powerful than actual words. Also, in interviews the expressions and emotions of the subject are viewed by the responder, as they see as well as here the news story which allows for a more detailed interpretation of the event.

4. During the last federal election campaign do you think the broadcast media focused more on issues or personalities? What could have been done better?
For this question I will discuss the current federal election campaign, as there is one in action at present due to the election on the 24th November, 2007. At present, the media are focusing more on the personalities of Kevin Rudd and John Howard. To be honest, the media are getting quite personal with their stories. I feel it would be better covered if the media focused more on the political issues and what each party are going to provide that will benefit Australia. This is what the majority of the public would rather be hearing. The personal aspects of either party are not the issue at hand and therefore should not be given so much attention from the media.

No comments: