Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Week 11- Chapter 11 Discussion Questions

1. You are a police reporter for a major city newspaper. A young man who seems credible tells you that he has been bashed by an off-duty police officer. He has witnesses and a medical report. A police officer tells you that no one will speak to you again if the newspaper runs anything, regardless of who writes it. The chief-of-staff says that if you do not write the story you will be removed from the round. What do you do?
Firstly, I would try to negotiate with the chief-of-staff and the police officer to see if either the police officer will cooperate or the chief-of-staff has an alternative angle to take on the story. Otherwise, I would write the story and submit it for publication. Although the police officer has made this threat, he may not be in the authoritative position to make such a comment and it may not be a legitimate claim. The police officer may simply be trying to cover the reputation of the other accused policeman. Also, there are other sources that the journalist will be able to gain information from. I would have to be careful in reporting only the basic facts to avoid contempt of court and misleading information on someone not yet found innocent or guilty. At the end of the day, the chief-of-staff is your boss.

2. A distraught woman convicted of stealing a pair of stockings from a store approaches you after her court case and says that she will commit suicide if you publish anything. Your newspaper has a policy of publishing all such cases, but it will never know about this one unless you reveal it. You really believe the woman might be suicidal. What do you do? Why?
I realise that journalists need to be thick-skinned and hard-nosed, however in this situation I would let the story go. Considering the lady’s claims to committing suicide I do not think that the story is that interesting and would be found enormously ground breaking and interesting to the public. The conviction is only minor and the woman obviously needs psychological help, not further humiliation in the media.

3. A very famous and very attractive personality gets hopelessly drunk at a party, causes chaos, and on the way home is picked up for drink-driving. You get a tip from a police contact and attend court where the personality is convicted of being three times over the limit, fined, and disqualified from driving. You are the only journalist in court. The personality later phones you and begs you not to write the story because it will ruin their career. They are so desperate they offer everything from sex to money and a free holiday if you do not report on the case. What will you do? Why?
I would report the case. It is my duty to serve the public and provide them with the public information they are entitled to. Regardless as to whether the person being reported on is an everyday person or a high profile person, the standard is still the same. I would therefore maintain the fairness in my reporting. It is similar to the 2004 case of Jeff Shaw’s criminal actions that regardless of his position within society were still published. This situation is no different and under no circumstances would I accept bribes in any form.

4. Although it is against the law, a juror in a high-profile murder trial approaches you and says there will be a hung jury in the case because two jury members have accepted bribes of $100 000 each from two corrupt high-ranking police officers who have paid the money on condition that the jurors do not return a guilty verdict. What will you do? Why?
I would stay quiet about the claim as it is against the law for a journalist to communicate with a juror prior to such a court case. I would attend the court case and then build my article on what happens in the court. If I was to take this information and publish it, I would not only be committing a crime myself but I would also be continuing a chain of corruption.

No comments: