1. A confidential source has tipped you off about what could be the story of the year, but they would prefer you to wait a day to write it. The source admits that another media outlet might have it too. You feel you need at least two days on it to do a good job. But it’s been a slow news day, and if you tell the chief-of-staff, you will be expected to write it to the best of your ability today. What do you do?
If it is a slow news day then I would grab it this opportunity immediately. This could be an excellent story as mentioned by the source and there is no way I would risk another newspaper distributing the lead story. I would speak to the chief-of-staff and use my day to produce the story to the best of my ability. Although the source has said that they would prefer if I waited, they have obviously tipped another outlet off as well who are more than likely going to try to print their own version of the story. I would go ahead and take advantage of the potential of the situation.
2. After a tip from an inside source you work on an article about filth in the kitchen of a major resort which has allegedly resulted in several guests and staff becoming ill. In the final stages of preparing your article you seek comment from the resort’s manager, who is hostile and refuses to comment. A short time later you receive a phone call from a leading public relations practitioner who tells you that the resort has been losing money and any bad publicity would force it to close with the loss of 120 jobs. Your source is one of the people who could be out of work. What will you do? Why?
Obviously I would consult with my chief-of-staff for advice, but my general opinion would be that the main function of journalism is to provide the public with the information that they are entitled to. If I was to withhold this information I would not be fulfilling my role as a journalist. For this reason I would go ahead and write the story. The fact that the problem is affecting the health of the general public as well as the refusal of the manager to comment both highlight a major problem that needs to be recognised not only by the public, but also by the relevant officials. In the short term jobs may be lost, however the long term benefits for both the employees and the public will be much better if the story is printed.
3. You are the late sub-editor for a daily newspaper. It is nearly 10pm. A man who identifies himself as a solicitor rings and says that a judge issued an order, after the journalist departed, prohibiting publication of a defendant’s name. He sounds drunk. The story, with the defendant’s name, is on the front page, which is about to be sent to the press. There is no time to call anyone without delaying the production process. What do you do?
After consideration, I would go ahead with the story. I realise there are huge defamation issues that would arise if the caller was legitimate, but too many factors challenge his story. Firstly, any journalist working in a professional organisation waits to the end of a court hearing before leaving and would therefore hear a vital point such as prohibited publication of the defendant’s name. Secondly, the caller has had all afternoon to contact the organisation, but has waited until 10pm at night. Lastly, the caller sounds drunk, which completely destroys his credibility as a solicitor or any other person with legitimate information on the matter. All these factors lead one to the conclusion that the phone call is most probably a hoax.
4. You are a junior journalist and you find yourself caught in the middle of an argument between the editor, who wants you to take one angle on a crime story, and the police rounds reporter who says the editor does not understand the full implications of the story and you should take a totally different angle. What will you do? Why?
I would listen to the editor as they are at much higher position than me and most probably have control over my position within the organisation. Although the police rounds reporter might have more knowledgeable on this particular issue, but the editor most probably would have more experience with the paper and in journalism itself.
Tuesday, October 9, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment