Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Week 13- Chpt 17- Discussion Questions

1. You are a newspaper editor. One of your reporters has made an honest mistake that defamed someone. You publish an apology. The person defamed is not satisfied and wants you to print a full-page feature story promoting her business or she will sue. What will you do?
I would print the feature story but only on her business. I would give no more attention to the act of defamation as I have already published a formal apology. For the sake of one day’s space in the paper, I would simply publish the feature story.

2. Would you support a ‘public figure’ defence for the media that would sharply limit the rights of public figures, ranging from premiers to cricketers and rock stars, to take out defamation suits against the media? Why?
Yes, I would support it because these people strive to get in the media all the time. They basically rely on the media as part of their promotional campaigns, yet when something is printed about them that they do not favour however little it may be, they make a defamation claim. If they want to be covered a lot in the media than they need to create a positive relationship with the media, one that can be relied upon not to turn on them at any opportunity.

3. You have promised a confidential source that you will not identify her. However, you discover that what she told you is untrue. Your newspaper is sued for defamation. You try to contact the person but she has vanished. Do you reveal her identity in court? Why?
Yes, the company would reveal her identity, as she is not only someone who has committed a crime concerning the media organisation but is now also a missing person and could be in danger. If I was to keep quiet about her, it would only worsen the already quickly deepening problem.

No comments: